| Actor | Character | Firearm | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Alexandra Boylan | Sophie | Flintlock Pistol | - |
| Alexandra Boylan | Sophie | Flintlock Pocket Pistol | - |
| David Shick | Blind Pew | Flintlock Pistol | non-firing replica |
| Jeff Denton | Dr. Livesley | Percussion Cap Pistol | - |
| Lance Henriksen | John Silver | Flintlock Pistol | - |
| Lance Henriksen | John Silver | Percussion Cap Pistol | - |
| Rebekah Kochan | Anne Bonney | Flintlock Pistol | non-firing replica |
| Rebekah Kochan | Anne Bonney | Blunderbuss | Percussion |