| Actor | Character | Firearm | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Allison Tolman | Deputy Molly Solverson | Smith & Wesson Model 13 | - |
| Allison Tolman | Deputy Molly Solverson | Remington 870 | - |
| Bob Odenkirk | Deputy Bill Oswalt | Colt Python | - |
| Glenn Howerton | Don Chumph | Remington 870 | Pistol gripped |
| Jordan Peele | Special Agent Webb Pepper | Glock 17 | - |
| Keegan-Michael Key | Special Agent Bill Budge | Glock 17 | - |
| Martin Freeman | Lester Nygaard | SIG-Sauer P226 | Nickel |
| Martin Freeman | Lester Nygaard | Smith & Wesson Model 66 | Snub-nosed |
| Martin Freeman | Lester Nygaard | 12 Gauge Double Barrelled Shotgun | - |
| Martin Freeman | Lester Nygaard | M249 SAW | - |