| Actor | Character | Firearm | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ana Ularu | Witch of the West | SIG-Sauer P220R | "Everybody Lies" (E05) |
| Florence Kasumba | Witch of the East | SIG-Sauer P220R | "The Beast Forever" (E01) |
| Gerran Howell | Jack | Unknown Pocket Pistol | "The Villain That's Become" (E09) |
| Oliver Jackson-Cohen | Lucas | SIG-Sauer P220R | "Mistress - New - Mistress" (E03) |
| Vincent D'Onofrio | The Wizard | SIG-Sauer P220R | "Beautiful Wickedness" (E06) |
| Vincent D'Onofrio | The Wizard | Fantasy pistol | based onRuger Mk.I/II |