| Actor | Character | Firearm | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Angus Macfadyen | Robert Rogers | Flintlock Fowler | S1E08 |
| Daniel Henshall | Caleb Brewster | Flintlock Pistol | S1E03 |
| Daniel Henshall | Caleb Brewster | Jäger Rifle | S1E03 |
| Jamie Bell | Abraham Woodhull | Flintlock Pistol | S1E07 |
| Jamie Bell | Abraham Woodhull | Flintlock Fowler | - |
| Jamie Bell | Abraham Woodhull | Kentucky Flintlock Rifle | - |
| Seth Numrich | Ben Talmadge | Flintlock Pistol | - |