| Actor | Character | Firearm | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Anson Mount | Cullen Bohannon | Remington 1858 New Army | Seasons2,3,4, and5 |
| Anson Mount | Cullen Bohannon | Winchester 1866 "Yellow Boy" | - |
| Chelah Horsdal | Maggie Palmer | Winchester 1866 "Yellow Boy" | (S3E09) |
| Christopher Heyerdahl | Thor "The Swede" Gundersen | Double Barreled Percussion Shotgun | - |
| Common | Elam Ferguson | Richards Cartridge Conversion | - |
| Common | Elam Ferguson | Winchester 1866 "Yellow Boy" | - |
| Common | Elam Ferguson | Sharps 1863 Saddle Ring Carbine | - |