| Actor | Character | Firearm | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Arthur Kennedy | Ned Sharp | Springfield Model 1866 | Model 1873 Cavalry Carbine |
| Errol Flynn | Colonel George Armstrong Custer | Single Action Army | "Cavalry" model, "Artillery" model; both with wooden grips |
| Errol Flynn | Colonel George Armstrong Custer | Remington 1875 | Dual-Wielded; probably a replica |
| Errol Flynn | Colonel George Armstrong Custer | Springfield Model 1866 | Model 1873 Rifle |
| Errol Flynn | Colonel George Armstrong Custer | Winchester Model 1892 Saddle Ring Carbine | Anachronistic; Rifle |