| Actor | Character | Firearm | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Asun Ortega | Sister Sarah | M1928 Thompson | - |
| Asun Ortega | Sister Sarah | Ruger GP100 | stainless 4” version |
| Asun Ortega | Sister Sarah | Smith & Wesson Schofield | engraved nickel version |
| Asun Ortega | Sister Sarah | Reck Miami 92F | nickel version |
| Asun Ortega | Sister Sarah | Colt 1878 | sawn-off barrel and stock |
| David Castro | Chavo | M1911A1 | - |
| David Castro | Chavo | Single Action Army | several replica versions |
| Maz Siam | Father Bernardo | Single Action Army | - |
| Perry D'Marco | Father Carlito | unidentified pistol | pistol hidden in cut-out bible |
| Xango Henry | Kick-Stand | Single Action Army | - |