| Actor | Character | Firearm | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Audrey Marie Anderson | Lyla Michaels | SIG-Sauer P226R | "AWOL" |
| Emily Bett Rickards | Felicity Smoak | Heckler & Koch MP5A3 | "Restoration" (S04E03) |
| Emily Kinney | Brie Larvan | Glock 17 | "Beacon of Hope" (S4E17) |
| Erik Palladino | Joyner | Beretta 92FS | "AWOL" (S4E11) |
| Eugene Byrd | Andy Diggle | SIG-Sauer P226 | "Genesis" |
| Eugene Byrd | Andy Diggle | Colt M4A1 | "AWOL", "Genesis" |
| Eugene Byrd | Andy Diggle | M72 LAW | "Genesis" |
| Madison McLaughlin | Evelyn Sharp | Taurus PT911 | "Canary Cry" (S04E18) |
| Willa Holland | Thea Queen | Smith & Wesson 3913 LS "Ladysmith" | "Lost in the Flood" (S04E22) |