| Barry Brown |
Henry Wheeler |
Springfield Model 1866 |
- |
| Cliff Robertson |
Cole Younger |
Winchester Model 1873 |
. |
| Cliff Robertson |
Cole Younger |
Single Action Army |
Nickel Artillery Model |
| Cliff Robertson |
Cole Younger |
Springfield Model 1866 |
. |
| Dana Elcar |
Allen |
Winchester Model 1873 |
. |
| Donald Moffat |
Anselm R. Manning |
Winchester Model 1873 |
. |
| Elisha Cook Jr. |
Alonzo Bunker |
Colt 1877 Thunderer Shopkeeper Model |
With wooden grips |
| Luke Askew |
Jim Younger |
Single Action Army |
"Quick-Draw" model with wooden grips; dual-wielded in some scenes |
| Luke Askew |
Jim Younger |
Winchester Model 1892 Saddle Ring Carbine |
Anachronistic; Saddle Ring Carbine |
| Matt Clark |
Jim Younger |
Single Action Army |
- |
| R.G. Armstrong |
Clell Miller |
Winchester Model 1892 Saddle Ring Carbine |
Anachronistic; Saddle Ring Carbine |
| Robert Duvall |
Jesse James |
Single Action Army |
Dual Cavalry models |