| Benjamin Bratt |
Tiberio Vargas |
Colt Buntline Special |
"Artillery" model, with nickel-plated finish |
| Benjamin Bratt |
Tiberio Vargas |
12 Gauge Double Barreled Shotgun |
- |
| Christoph Waltz |
Max Borlund |
Colt New Service |
With 7.5" barrel |
| Christoph Waltz |
Max Borlund |
Winchester Model 1892 Saddle Ring Carbine |
Saddle Ring Carbine, Denix replica |
| Christoph Waltz |
Max Borlund |
Winchester Model 1894 |
With target sights |
| Rachel Brosnahan |
Rachel Kidd |
Colt 4th Model Derringer |
- |
| Rachel Brosnahan |
Rachel Kidd |
Colt Buntline Special |
"Artillery" model, with wooden grips |
| Willem Dafoe |
Joe Cribbens |
Smith & Wesson .44 Double Action |
- |