| Actor | Character | Firearm | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bill Paxton | Frank James | Colt 1851 Navy | - |
| Bill Paxton | Frank James | Remington 1858 New Army | - |
| Bill Paxton | Frank James | Single Action Army | - |
| Dana Wheeler-Nicholson | Annie | Winchester Model 1873 | - |
| John Pyper-Ferguson | Clell Miller | Single Action Army | - |
| Luke Askew | Lone Rider | Remington New Army | Uberti replica, with blued finish and wooden grips |
| Maria Pitillo | Zee James | Sharps Pepperbox | - |
| Nicholas Sadler | Arch Clements | Remington 1858 New Army | . |
| Nicholas Sadler | Arch Clements | Webley Mk I | . |
| Nicholas Sadler | Arch Clements | Winchester Model 1897 Riot Gun | Anachronism |
| Randy Travis | Cole Younger | Colt 1878 | - |
| Randy Travis | Cole Younger | Single Action Army | - |
| Randy Travis | Cole Younger | Winchester Model 1887 | - |
| Rob Lowe | Jesse James | Colt 1851 Navy | - |
| Rob Lowe | Jesse James | Single Action Army | - |
| Todd Field | Bob Younger | Single Action Army | - |
| Todd Field | Bob Younger | Winchester Model 1897 Riot Gun | - |
| William Atherton | Allan Pinkerton | Single Action Army | - |
| William Atherton | Allan Pinkerton | Webley Mk I | - |