| Actor | Character | Firearm | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bill Tangradi | Nathan | Single Action Army | In holster |
| Bill Tangradi | Nathan | Vz. 98/22 Czech Mauser | - |
| Bill Tangradi | Nathan | Winchester Model 1866 "Yellow Boy" | - |
| Dakota Fanning | Liz | Unidentified revolver | SupposedlySmith & Wesson Model 3or some similar model |
| Dakota Fanning | Liz | Winchester Model 1866 "Yellow Boy" | - |
| Dakota Fanning | Liz | IZh-18(mocked up as flintlock pistol) | - |
| Guy Pearce | The Reverend | Werndl Karabiner M1867/77 | With sniper scope |
| Kit Harington | Samuel | Single Action Army | In holster |
| Kit Harington | Samuel | Richards Cartridge Conversion | Denixnon-firing replica |
| Kit Harington | Samuel | Accles & Shelvoke Cashcaptive bolt pistol | - |
| Paul Anderson | Frank | Single Action Army | - |
| William Houston | Eli | IZh-18(mocked up as flintlock pistol) | - |
| Dakota Fanning | Liz | IZh-18 | - |