| Actor | Character | Firearm | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Billy Jaye | Mickey | M1911A1 | - |
| Dustin Hoffman | Dutch Schultz | M1911A1 | - |
| Dustin Hoffman | Dutch Schultz | Colt Model 1903/1908 | - |
| John Costelloe | Lulu Rosenkrantz | M1911A1 | - |
| Loren Dean | Billy Bathgate | Colt Police Positive | . |
| Steve Buscemi | Irving | Colt Model 1903/1908 | . |