| Billy Malone |
Chet Finch |
Colt Gold Cup National Match |
"Who Framed The Good Cop" (S1E01) |
| Josh Groban |
Detective Tony Caruso Jr. |
Glock 19 |
- |
| Josh Groban |
Detective Tony Caruso Jr. |
Kahr M9098 Elite 2003 |
- |
| Josh Groban |
Detective Tony Caruso Jr. |
Smith & Wesson M&P9 |
- |
| Josh Groban |
Detective Tony Caruso Jr. |
Smith & Wesson 5904 |
continuity error |
| Monica Barbaro |
Det. Cora Vasquez |
Kahr M9098 Elite 2003 |
"Who Framed The Good Cop" (S1E01) |
| Monica Barbaro |
Det. Cora Vasquez |
Glock 19 |
- |
| Tony Danza |
Tony Caruso Sr. |
Smith & Wesson Model 640 Centennial |
"Will Cora Get Married?" (S1E08) |