| Actor | Character | Firearm | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brad Carter | Deputy Branigan | Single Action Army | - |
| Max Arciniega | Stilwell | Smith & Wesson Military & Police | 2nd Model of 1902; 5" barrel |
| Max Arciniega | Stilwell | Smith & Wesson Victory Model | 4" barrel |
| Max Arciniega | Stilwell | Sharps 1874 Long Range | - |
| Richard Speight, Jr. | Duggan | Colt New Service | Ivory grips |
| Richard Speight, Jr. | Duggan | Single Barreled Shotgun | - |
| Scott Haze | Sheriff Curry | Single Action Army | - |
| Stephen Dorff | Ketchum | Sharps 1874 Long Range | - |
| Stephen Dorff | Ketchum | Remington 1875 | 5.5" barrel |
| Stephen Dorff | Ketchum | Colt Official Police | - |
| Tim Blake Nelson | Henry MacCarty | Single Action Army | - |
| Tim Blake Nelson | Henry MacCarty | Winchester Model 1894 | Angle Eject Carbine |
| Tim Blake Nelson | Henry MacCarty | Double Barreled Shotgun | - |
| Trace Adkins | Uncle Al | Winchester Model 1897 Riot Gun | - |