| Bud Spencer |
Father Pedro de Leon |
Single Action Army |
Armi Jager replica, "Quick-Draw' model with brass grip frames and wooden grips |
| Robert Loggia |
Governor Alfonso Felipe Gonzaga |
Single Action Army |
Uberti replica, "Quick-Draw' model with brass grip frames and wooden grips |
| Robert Loggia |
Governor Alfonso Felipe Gonzaga |
Remington New Army |
Uberti replica, with blued finish |
| Terence Hill |
Father J. |
Remington Double Derringer |
With blued finish and wooden grips; wooden mock-up in some scenes |
| Terence Hill |
Father J. |
Colt 1851 Navy |
Probably a Uberti replica |
| Terence Hill |
Father J. |
Winchester Model 1866 "Yellow Boy" |
Early Uberti replica, with brass bands and sling attached |