| Actor | Character | Firearm | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chill Wills | Blue Duck | Remington 1858 | - |
| Dana Andrews | Maj. Thomas Crail | Richards Cartridge Conversion | - |
| Gene Tierney | Belle Starr | Remington 1858 | - |
| Gene Tierney | Belle Starr | Springfield Model 1866 | - |
| Randolph Scott | Sam Starr | Remington New Army | With stainless-steel finish and pearl grips |
| Randolph Scott | Sam Starr | Springfield Model 1866 | Model 1873 Cavalry Carbine |
| Chill Wills | Blue Duck | Remington New Army | With "long cylinder" cartridge conversion, blued finish, and ivory grips |