| Chris Penn |
Gaetano "Tommy" Reina |
Boot Pistol |
- |
| Christian Slater |
Charlie "Lucky" Luciano |
Colt Police Positive |
- |
| Christian Slater |
Charlie "Lucky" Luciano |
M1911 |
- |
| Christian Slater |
Charlie "Lucky" Luciano |
M1921 Thompson |
- |
| Costas Mandylor |
Frank Costello |
Remington 870 |
sawed-off; anachronistic |
| Costas Mandylor |
Frank Costello |
Winchester Model 1897 Riot Gun |
- |
| Nicholas Sadler |
Vincent "Mad Dog" Coll |
Colt Official Police |
. |
| Nicholas Sadler |
Vincent "Mad Dog" Coll |
Colt 1921A Thompson |
. |
| Patrick Dempsey |
Meyer Lansky |
Colt Detective Special |
- |
| Richard Grieco |
Benjamin "Bugsy" Siegel |
Smith & Wesson Model 10 |
- |
| Richard Grieco |
Benjamin "Bugsy" Siegel |
Thompson M1921 |
- |
| Richard Grieco |
Benjamin "Bugsy" Siegel |
Remington Mark III Flare Pistol |
- |
| Richard Grieco |
Benjamin "Bugsy" Siegel |
Remington 870 |
- |
| Richard Grieco |
Benjamin "Bugsy" Siegel |
Rossi Overland |
- |