| Actor | Character | Firearm | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Clancy Brown | Curly Joe | Single Action Army | "Cavalry", "Artillery" and "Civilian" models |
| Grainger Hines | Mr. Arthur | Henry Rifle | - |
| Grainger Hines | Mr. Arthur | Colt 1872 Open Top | - |
| James Franco | Cowboy | Single Action Army | "Cavalry" model |
| Jesse Luken | Drover | Single Action Army | "Cavalry" model |
| Matthew Willig | Cantina Scum | Single Action Army | "Cavalry" model |
| Ralph Ineson | Posse Leader | Single Action Army | "Cavalry" model |
| Richard Bucher | Posse #4 | Smith & Wesson No. 3 Russian Model | - |
| Richard Bucher | Posse #4 | Winchester Model 1876 | - |
| Stephen Root | The bank teller | Colt Model 1878 | Coach Gun |
| Tim Blake Nelson | Buster Scruggs | Single Action Army | Nickel plated "Artillery" model |
| Tim Blake Nelson | Buster Scruggs | Remington Double Derringer | Matching pair, nickel plated with pearl grips |
| Tom Waits | The old prospector | Colt Paterson 1836 | - |
| Zoe Kazan | Alice Longabaugh | Colt 1872 Open Top | - |