| Actor | Character | Firearm | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Clancy Brown | Sheriff August Corbin | Glock 17 | "Pilot" (S1E01) |
| Dwayne Boyd | Sleepy Hollow Police Officer | Remington 870 | - |
| Janina Gavankar | Diana Thomas | Beretta PX4 | S04 |
| John Cho | Deputy Andy Brooks | Glock 17 | "Pilot" (S1E01) |
| Nicole Beharie | Grace Abigail "Abbie" Mills | Glock 17 | "Pilot" (S1E01) |
| Tom Mison | Ichabod Crane | Flintlock Pistol | "Pilot" (S1E01) |
| Tom Mison | Ichabod Crane | Charleville Musket | "Pilot" (S1E01) |