| Actor | Character | Firearm | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Colin Cunningham | Nicky | SIG-Sauer P226 | "Insurgence" (S2E12) |
| Garwin Sanford | Ed Brooks | Walther PP Non Gun | "Red" (S2E04) |
| John Schneider | Jonathan Kent | Winchester Model 1873 | "Heat" (S2E02) |
| John Schneider | Jonathan Kent | Beretta 92FS Inox | "Suspect" (S2E13) |
| Karen Holness | Bishop | Walther PP Non Gun | "Insurgence" (S2E12) |
| Michael Tomlinson | Ted Palmer | Glock 17 | "Red" |
| Mitchell Kosterman | Ethan Miller | Beretta 92FS Inox | "Suspect" (S2E13) |
| Mitchell Kosterman | Ethan Miller | Glock 17 | "Suspect" (S2E13) |
| Paul Wesley | Lucas Luthor | Glock 17 | "Prodigal" (S2E15) |
| Tom Welling | Clark Kent | Glock 17 | "Red" (S2E04) |