| Colin Farrell |
Jesse James |
Springfield Model 1863 |
- |
| Colin Farrell |
Jesse James |
Colt 1851 Navy |
dual-wielded |
| Colin Farrell |
Jesse James |
Colt 1849 Pocket |
dual-wielded |
| Colin Farrell |
Jesse James |
Colt 1851 Navy (Richards-Mason Conversion) |
- |
| Gabriel Macht |
Frank James |
Henry 1860 |
- |
| Gabriel Macht |
Frank James |
Colt 1849 Pocket |
- |
| Gabriel Macht |
Frank James |
Colt 1851 Navy (Richards-Mason Conversion) |
dual wielded |
| Gregory Smith |
Jim Younger |
Colt 1851 Navy |
Richards-Mason conversion |
| Scott Caan |
Cole Younger |
Colt 1851 Navy |
- |
| Scott Caan |
Cole Younger |
Double Barreled Shotgun |
- |
| Scott Caan |
Cole Younger |
Colt 1851 Navy (Richards-Mason Conversion) |
- |
| Timothy Dalton |
Allan Pinkerton |
Colt 1851 Navy |
Richards-Mason conversion |