| Actor | Character | Firearm | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dale Gibson | Cleet Utley | Remington 1875 | Nickel plated |
| Lou Diamond Phillips | Bobby Hattaway | Single Action Army | - |
| Lou Diamond Phillips | Bobby Hattaway | Colt Walker | - |
| Lou Diamond Phillips | Bobby Hattaway | Winchester Model 1873 | - |
| Lou Diamond Phillips | Bobby Hattaway | Double Barreled Shotgun | - |
| Lou Diamond Phillips | Bobby Hattaway | Remington 1875 | Nickel plated; only on film poster |
| Stacy Keach | Robert Hattaway | Winchester Model 1866 "Yellow Boy" | Uberti replica, Saddle Ring Carbine |
| Timothy Bottoms | Sheriff Gus Keagle | Colt 1871-72 Open Top | - |
| Tom Schanley | Mike Butler | Smith & Wesson Schofield | - |
| Tom Schanley | Mike Butler | Springfield 1873 Trapdoor Carbine | - |
| Vincent Spano | Stu Croker | Remington 1875 | Nickel plated |