| Actor | Character | Firearm | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Darren McGavin | Captain Benton | Colt Buntline Special | "Cavalry" model |
| Joseph Cotten | Mayor Reno | Colt Buntline Special | "Cavalry" model |
| Joseph Cotten | Major Reno | Colt Single Action Army | "Cavalry" model |
| Philip Carey | Lt. Col. George Armstrong Custer | Single Action Army | "Cavalry" model with wooden grips |
| Darren McGavin | Captain Benton | Colt Single Action Army | "Cavalry" model |