| Actor | Character | Firearm | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ed Harris | Sheriff Cornelius Jackson | Single Action Army | Cavalry Model |
| Ed Harris | Sheriff Cornelius Jackson | Winchester Model 1887 | - |
| Eduardo Noriega | Miguel Ramírez | Remington 1875 | - |
| Eduardo Noriega | Miguel Ramírez | Winchester Model 1866 "Yellow Boy" | - |
| January Jones | Sarah Ramírez | Remington 1875 | - |
| January Jones | Sarah Ramírez | Single Action Army | Cavalry Mode |
| January Jones | Sarah Ramírez | Winchester Model 1866 "Yellow Boy" | - |
| Jason Aldean | Daniel | Winchester Model 1887 | - |
| Jason Isaacs | Prophet Josiah | Single Action Army | Cavalry Model |
| Luce Rains | Kingfisher | Single Action Army | - |