| Elizabeth Blackmore |
Lady Antonia Bevell |
M1911A1 |
- |
| Felicia Day |
Charlie Bradbury |
FNP-45 |
Season 13,Season 14,Season 15 |
| Jensen Ackles |
Dean Winchester |
Calico M960A |
"All Along the Watchtower" (S12E23) |
| Jim Beaver |
Bobby Singer |
Franchi PA3/215 |
"All Along the Watchtower" (S12E23) |
| Mark Pellegrino |
Lucifer |
Calico M960A |
"All Along the Watchtower" (S12E23) |
| Misha Collins |
Castiel |
Colt Paterson 1836 |
Pietta Paterson Extra Deluxe with cartridge conversion; "The Future" (S12E19) |
| Nathan Mitchell |
Kelvin |
Colt Paterson 1836 |
Pietta Paterson Extra Deluxe w/cartridge conversion; "The Future" (S12E19) |
| Samantha Smith |
Mary Winchester |
M1911A1 |
"First Blood" (S12E09) |
| Shoshannah Stern |
Eileen Leahy |
Colt Paterson 1836 |
Pietta Paterson Extra Deluxe w/cartridge conversion; "The British Invasion" (S12E17) |