| Adam David Thompson |
Gatz Brown |
Colt 1871-72 Open Top |
Ivory grips |
| Adam David Thompson |
Gatz Brown |
Winchester Model 1866 "Yellow Boy" |
- |
| Adam David Thompson |
Gatz Brown |
Coach Gun |
- |
| Ali Agirnas |
Nicholas Gustavson |
Winchester Model 1866 "Yellow Boy" |
- |
| Christiane Seidel |
Martha Bishop |
Single Action Army |
4.75 inch "civilian" model |
| Christiane Seidel |
Martha Bishop |
Winchester Model 1873 |
carbine |
| Erik LaRay Harvey |
Elias Hobbs |
12 Gauge Double Barreled Shotgun |
"Wisdom of the Horse" (S1E03) |
| Erik LaRay Harvey |
Elias Hobbs |
Remington Model 1875 |
"Homecoming" (S1E07) |
| Jack O'Connell |
Roy Goode |
Winchester Model 1866 "Yellow Boy" |
- |
| Jack O'Connell |
Roy Goode |
Colt 1871-72 Open Top |
- |
| Jack O'Connell |
Roy Goode |
Single Action Army |
- |
| Jack O'Connell |
Roy Goode |
Henry 1860 |
- |
| Jeff Daniels |
Frank Griffin |
Remington 1875 |
- |
| Jeff Daniels |
Frank Griffin |
Colt 1849 Pocket |
- |
| Jeff Daniels |
Frank Griffin |
Colt 1871-72 Open Top |
- |
| Jeff Daniels |
Frank Griffin |
Winchester Model 1866 "Yellow Boy" |
- |
| Joe Pingue |
Alonzo Bunker |
Remington 1875 |
- |
| Justin Welborn |
Floyd Wilson |
Single Action Army |
- |
| Keith Jardine |
Dyer Howe |
Smith & Wesson New Model No.3 |
Seen only in holster |
| Kim Coates |
Ed Logan |
Smith & Wesson No.3 Russian Model |
- |
| Kim Coates |
Ed Logan |
Winchester Model 1873 |
- |
| Luke Robertson |
Bill Chick |
Single Action Army |
- |
| Merritt Wever |
Mary Agnes McNue |
Single Action Army |
- |
| Merritt Wever |
Mary Agnes McNue |
Winchester Model 1876 |
- |
| Merritt Wever |
Mary Agnes McNue |
Double Barreled Shotgun |
- |
| Michelle Dockery |
Alice Fletcher |
Henry 1860 |
Trapper Iron Frame |
| Nathan Darrow |
Webster |
Unidentified Smith & Wesson top break revolver |
- |
| Randy Oglesby |
Asa Leopold |
Remington 1875 |
Nickel plated |
| Rio Alexander |
Bud Ledbetter |
Single Action Army |
- |
| Sam Waterston |
Marshal John Cook |
Smith & Wesson Schofield |
Ivory grips |
| Samantha Soule |
Charlotte Temple |
Merwin Hulbert pocket revolver |
- |
| Scoot McNairy |
Bill McNue |
Single Action Army |
- |
| Scoot McNairy |
Bill McNue |
Winchester Model 1873 |
- |
| Tantoo Cardinal |
Iyovi |
Sharps 1863 Carbine |
- |
| Thomas Brodie-Sangster |
Deputy Whitey Winn |
Single Action Army |
Pair of nickel plated revolvers with ivory grips |
| Thomas Brodie-Sangster |
Deputy Whitey Winn |
Remington 1875 |
- |
| Thomas Brodie-Sangster |
Deputy Whitey Winn |
Winchester Model 1873 |
- |