| Actor | Character | Firearm | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hannah New | Eleanor Guthrie | Flintlock Fowler | Ep. "XIV." |
| Luke Arnold | "Long" John Silver | Flintlock Pistol | Ep. "IX." |
| Robert Hobbs | Jenks | Flintlock Pistol | - |
| Toby Stephens | Captain James Flint | Flintlock Pistol | - |
| Tom Hopper | William "Billy Bones" Manderly | Flintlock Pistol | Ep. "XVIII." |
| Zach McGowan | Captain Charles Vane | Brown Bess Carbine | Ep. "XVIII." |
| Zach McGowan | Captain Charles Vane | Queen Anne Flintlock Pistol | Ep. "XVIII." |
| Zach McGowan | Captain Charles Vane | Flintlock Pistol | Ep. "XVIII." |