| Actor | Character | Firearm | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Iddo Goldberg | Isaac Walton | Blunderbuss | "The Vow" (S1E01) |
| Iddo Goldberg | Isaac Walton | Flintlock Pistol | "The Witching Hour" (S2E13) |
| Kevin Tighe | Giles Corey | Matchlock Musket | "The Vow" (S1E01) |
| Shane West | Captain John Alden | Flintlock Pistol | Seasons1,2and3 |
| Shane West | Captain John Alden | Blunderbuss | "The Vow" (S1E01) |
| Shane West | Captain John Alden | Matchlock Musket | "The Vow" (S1E01) |
| Shane West | Captain John Alden | Trade Musket | Seasons2and3 |