| Adam Williams |
Pauk Loper |
Colt Buntline Special |
"Dos Pinos" (S1E05): "Artillery" model |
| Brian Keith |
Dave Blassingame |
Winchester Model 1895 |
Throughout the series; Sporterized model with telescopic sight |
| Brian Keith |
Dave Blassingame |
Single Action Army |
Throughout the series; seen only in holster; "Artillery" model with wooden grips |
| Charles Horvath |
Crow |
12 Gauge Double Barreled Shotgun |
"Jeff" (S1E01); With exposed hammers |
| Ethan Laidlaw |
Rancher |
12 Gauge Double Barreled Shotgun |
“The Painting” (S1E13) |
| Geoffrey Toone |
Danny Lipp |
Winchester Model 1895 |
"Jeff" (S1E01); Sporterized model with a telescopic scope |
| Hank Gobble |
Digger |
Colt 1877 Thunderer Shopkeeper Model |
"Brown" (S1E03) |
| Hank Gobble |
Digger |
Colt Buntline Special |
"Brown" (S1E03); Continuity error, seen only in holster |
| Harry Swoger |
Sheriff Tom Lacette |
Winchester Model 1895 |
"Brown" (S1E03); Sporterized model with a telescopic sight |
| Jack Kruschen |
Rigdon |
Sharps 1863 Carbine |
“Going Home” (S1E11) |
| James Anderson |
Frank Ritchie |
Colt Buntline Special |
"School Days" (S1E02); "Artillery" model |
| John Anderson |
Leth Ritchie |
Winchester Model 1892 Saddle Ring Carbine |
"School Days" (S1E02); Saddle Ring Carbine |
| Joseph Wiseman |
Serafin |
Single Action Army |
“Ghost of a Chance” (S1E09); "Artillery" model |
| Katy Jurado |
Carlotta |
Single Action Army |
“Ghost of a Chance" (S1E09); "Quick-Draw" model with wooden grips |
| Malcolm Atterbury |
Sheriff Frank Dollar |
Colt Buntline Special |
"Treasure" (S1E09); "Quick-Draw" model |
| Richard Rust |
Deputy Tyson |
Single Action Army |
"School Days" (S1E02); "Quick-Draw" model with wooden grips |
| Richard Rust |
Deputy Tyson |
Winchester Model 1895 |
"School Days" (S1E02); Sporterized model with telescopic sight |
| Sam Jaffe |
McKee/Old Man |
Colt Buntline Special |
“The Old Man” (S1E08); Mocked-up as aRemington 1858 New Army |
| William Tracy |
Doug Ritchie |
Winchester Model 1892 Saddle Ring Carbine |
"School Days" (S1E02); Saddle Ring Carbine |