| Actor | Character | Firearm | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Joel McCrea | Steve Judd | Single Action Army | "Cavalry" model with wooden grips |
| Joel McCrea | Steve Judd | Winchester Model 1894 | Saddle Ring Carbine; with saddle ring removed |
| Randolph Scott | Gil Westrum | Remington 1875 | "Frontier" model with pearl grips |
| Warren Oates | Henry Hammond | Single Action Army | "Sheriff's" model with wooden grips |
| Warren Oates | Henry Hammond | Remington Model 8 | With 5-round magazine |