| Actor | Character | Firearm | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| John Dall | Bart Tare | Colt Official Police | - |
| John Dall | Bart Tare | English dueling pistols | - |
| John Dall | Bart Tare | Remington .22 cal pump-action rifle | - |
| Peggy Cummins | Annie Laurie Starr | Colt Police Positive | nickel plated with pearl grips |
| Peggy Cummins | Annie Laurie Starr | Nickel Plated Revolvers | Possibly Colt DA revolvers |
| Russ Tamblyn | Bart Tare | Colt Police Positive | With 4" barrel and factory wooden grips |
| Russ Tamblyn | Bart Tare | Pump-Action Rifle | - |
| Russ Tamblyn | Bart Tare | M1917 Revolver | With wooden stag-horn grips |