| John Neville |
'The Well-Manicured Man' |
Star Firestar M-43 |
Blued / "Patient X" (S5E13) |
| Luke Wilson |
Sheriff Hartwell |
Smith & Wesson Model 586 |
4" barrel / "Bad Blood" (S5E12) |
| Martin Ferrero |
'The Shooter' |
Remington 700 |
Fitted with Choate Ultimate Sniper Stock / "The End" (S5E20) |
| Michael Shamus Wiles |
'The Black-Haired Man' |
Smith & Wesson 5946 |
Suppressed / "The End" (S5E20) |
| Scott Burkholder |
FBI Special Agent Michael Kinsley |
SIG-Sauer P226 |
"Detour" (S5E04) |
| Steven Williams |
Mr. X |
Rossi Model 68 |
Snub-nose, stainless / "Unusual Suspects" (S5E03) |