| Actor | Character | Firearm | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jovan Adepo | Will Reeve | Smith & Wesson Model 10 | "This Extraordinary Being" (S1E06) |
| Regina King | Angela Abar aka Sister Night | SIG-Sauer P226 | - |
| Regina King | Angela Abar aka Sister Night | Springfield Armory XD | - |
| Tim Blake Nelson | Wade Tillman aka Looking Glass | Ruger GP100 | "Little Fear of Lightning" (S1E05) |
| Tom Mison | The Game Warden | Blunderbuss | "See How They Fly" (S1E09) |