| Actor | Character | Firearm | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Justin Hartley | Colter Shaw | Para-Ordnance P-14 Limited | - |
| Justin Hartley | Colter Shaw | SIG-Sauer P320-M17 | - |
| Justin Hartley | Colter Shaw | Walther P99 | "Chicago" (S1E07) |
| Justin Hartley | Colter Shaw | M1911A1 | "Off the Books" (S1E12) |
| Justin Hartley | Colter Shaw | Smith & Wesson Model 19 | "Chicago" (S1E07) |
| Justin Hartley | Colter Shaw | Remington Model 700 | "St. Louis" (S1E05) |
| Justin Hartley | Colter Shaw | Remington Model 870 Police Magnum | "Nightingale" (S2E10) |