| Christie McNab |
Abigail Abington |
Single Action Army |
Modern replica, "Cavalry" model with iron grip frames and wooden grips |
| Drew Waters |
Jeremiah Handle |
Single Action Army |
Modern replica, "Cavalry" model with iron grip frames and wooden grips |
| Gregory Cruz |
Bugle Bearclaw |
Single Action Army |
Modern replica, "Cavalry" model with iron grip frames and wooden grips |
| Gregory Cruz |
Bugle Bearclaw |
Henry 1860 |
Uberti replica, with brass frame |
| Gregory Cruz |
Bugle Bearclaw |
Sharps 1863 Carbine |
Saddle Ring Carbine, with sling attached |
| Gregory Cruz |
Bugle Bearclaw |
Spencer 1860 Carbine |
Saddle Ring Carbine, with sling attached |
| Isaiah Stratton |
Franklin York |
Single Action Army |
Anachronistic; modern replica, "Cavalry" model with iron grip frames and wooden grips |
| Isaiah Stratton |
Franklin York |
Sharps 1874 |
Anachronistic; Uberti replica, with telescopic sight attached |
| Michael McDonough |
Perkins St. Denis |
Berdan Sharps 1859 Rifle |
With sling attached |
| Michael McDonough |
Perkins St. Denis |
Sharps 1863 Carbine |
Saddle Ring Carbine, with sling attached |
| Roxanna Dunlop |
Stacey Snyder |
Colt 1851 Navy |
Uberti replica, with anachronistic cartridge conversion |
| Roxanna Dunlop |
Stacey Snyder |
Single Action Army |
Modern replica, "Cavalry" model with iron grip frames and wooden grips |
| Steven R. McQueen |
Cal Breaker |
Colt 1851 Navy |
Uberti replica, with anachronistic cartridge conversion |
| Steven R. McQueen |
Cal Breaker |
Henry 1860 |
Uberti replica, with brass frame |
| Steven R. McQueen |
Cal Breaker |
Sharps 1863 Carbine |
Saddle Ring Carbine, with sling attached |
| Steven R. McQueen |
Cal Breaker |
Spencer 1860 Carbine |
Saddle Ring Carbine, with sling attached |
| Trace Cheramie |
George Washington Jr. |
Single Action Army |
Dual-wielded; Modern replica, "Cavalry" model with iron grip frames and wooden grips |
| Greg Perrow |
Deputy Shanks |
Colt 1851 Navy |
Uberti replica, with anachronistic cartridge conversion |
| Greg Perrow |
Deputy Shanks |
Single Action Army |
Modern replica, "Cavalry" model with iron grip frames and wooden grips |
| Greg Perrow |
Deputy Shanks |
Henry 1860 |
Uberti replica, with brass frame |
| Casper Van Dien |
Virgil St. Denis |
Single Action Army |
Modern replica, "Cavalry" model with iron grip frames and wooden grips; dual-wielded in some scenes |
| Casper Van Dien |
Virgil St. Denis |
Remington New Army |
Uberti replica, with cartridge conversion, blued finish, and wooden grips |
| Casper Van Dien |
Virgil St. Denis |
Berdan Sharps 1859 Rifle |
With sling attached |
| Casper Van Dien |
Virgil St. Denis |
Sharps 1863 Carbine |
Saddle Ring Carbine, with sling attached |
| Casper Van Dien |
Virgil St. Denis |
Spencer 1860 Carbine |
Saddle Ring Carbine, with sling attached |
| Gregory Alan Williams |
Tucker Macready |
Single Action Army |
Modern replica, "Cavalry" model, "Quick-Draw" model; both with iron grip frames and wooden grips |
| Gregory Alan Williams |
Tucker Macready |
Henry 1860 |
Uberti replica, with brass frame |
| Gregory Alan Williams |
Tucker Macready |
Rossi Overland |
Anachronsitic |
| Neal McDonough |
John Breaker |
Single Action Army |
Modern replica, with iron grip frames and wooden grips |
| Neal McDonough |
John Breaker |
Remington New Army |
With "long cylinder" cartridge conversion, blued finish, and wooden grips |
| Neal McDonough |
John Breaker |
Henry 1860 |
Uberti replica, with brass frame |
| Neal McDonough |
John Breaker |
Sharps 1874 |
Continuity error; Uberti replica |
| Neal McDonough |
John Breaker |
Winchester Model 1866 "Yellow Boy" |
Anachronistic; Uberti replica, Saddle Ring Carbine; with sling attached |
| Neal McDonough |
John Breaker |
Winchester Model 1892 Saddle Ring Carbine |
Anachronistic; Saddle Ring Carbine |