| Grant Woods |
Capt. Mylew Keogh |
Single Action Army |
"Sabers in the Sun" (S1E1); "Cavalry" model with wooden grips; visually modified to resemble aRemington New Army |
| Michael Dante |
Crazy Horse |
12 Gauge Double Barreled Shotgun |
"Sabers in the Sun" (S1E1); with ecposed hammers |
| Peter Palmer |
Sgt. James Bustard |
Single Action Army |
"Sabers in the Sun" (S1E1); "Cavalry" model with wooden grips; visually modified to resemble aRemington New Army |
| Peter Palmer |
Sgt. James Bustard |
Colt 1860 Army |
"Sabers in the Sun" (S1E1); anachronistic; with Richards Cartridge Conversion, 5.5" barrel, and iron grip frames |
| Wayne Maunder |
Lt. Col. George Armstrong Custer |
Single Action Army |
"Sabers in the Sun" (S1E1); "Cavalry" model with wooden grips; visually modified to resemble aRemington New Army |
| Wayne Maunder |
Lt. Col. George Armstrong Custer |
Springfield Model 1866 |
"Sabers in the Sun" (S1E1); anachronistic; Model 1873 Cavalry Carbine |
| William Mims |
Lt. Col. George Armstrong Custer |
Winchester Model 1873 |
"Sabers in the Sun" (S1E1); anachronistic; Short Rifle with short tube magazine |
| William Mims |
Lt. Col. George Armstrong Custer |
12 Gauge Double Barreled Shotgun |
"Sabers in the Sun" (S1E1); with exposed hammers |
| Robert F. Simon |
Gen. Alfred H. Terry |
Colt 1860 Army |
"Sabers in the Sun" (S1E1); anachronistic; with Richards Cartridge Conversion, 5.5" barrel, and iron grip frames |
| Michael Dante |
Crazy Horse |
Springfield Model 1866 |
"Accused" (S1E2); anachronistic; Model 1884 Cavalry Carbine |
| Chris Robinson |
Lt. Tim Rudford |
Single Action Army |
"Accused" (S1E2); "Cavalry" model with wooden grips; visually modified to resemble aRemington New Army |
| Slim Pickens |
California Joe Milner |
Sharps 1863 Carbine |
"Sabers in the Sun" (S1E1); Saddle Ring Carbine |
| Slim Pickens |
California Joe Milner |
Winchester Model 1873 |
Throughout the series; anachronistic; Rifle |
| Jack Hogan |
Sgt. Mason |
Single Action Army |
"Accused" (S1E2); "Cavalry" model with wooden grips; visually modified to resemble aRemington New Army |
| Jack Hogan |
Sgt. Mason |
Springfield Model 1866 |
"Accused" (S1E2); anachronistic; Model 1873 Cavalry Carbine |
| Rodolfo Acosta |
Satanta |
12 Gauge Double Barreled Shotgun |
"Sabers in the Sun" (S1E1); with exposed hammers |