| Actor | Character | Firearm | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Alan Hale Jr. | Sgt. Beauregard Davis | Remington 1858 New Army | - |
| Alan Hale Jr. | Sgt. Beauregard Davis | Springfield Model 1866 | with M1855 bayonet |
| Andrew Prine | Pvt. Owen Selous | Springfield Model 1866 | with M1855 bayonet |
| Chuck Roberson | Monk | Remington 1858 New Army | - |
| Glenn Ford | Capt. Jared Heath | Remington New Army | With blued finish and wooden grips |
| James Griffith | Hugo Zattig | Remington 1858 New Army | - |
| Jesse Pearson | Cpl. Silas Geary | Remington 1858 New Army | - |
| Jim Backus | Gen. Willoughby | Remington 1858 New Army | - |
| Stella Stevens | Martha Lou Williams | Remington 1858 New Army | - |
| Stella Stevens | Martha Lou Williams | replica Remington 1858 New Army | - |
| Stella Stevens | Martha Lou Williams | unknown derringer | - |