| Alan Hale Sr. |
Sheriff Harris |
Remington Rolling Block |
Pistol; dual-wielded in some scenes |
| Alan Hale Sr. |
Sheriff Harris |
Colt Dragoon |
Anachronistic; 1st Model; dual-wielded in some scenes |
| Ian MacDonald |
Miller |
Remington Rolling Block |
Seen only in holster; Pistol |
| Lloyd Bridges |
Paul Donovan |
Remington Rolling Block |
Pistol |
| Luther Crockett |
Judge Tucker |
Remington Rolling Block |
Pistol |
| Randolph Scott |
Steve Farrell |
Single Action Army |
Anachronistic; seen only in holster; dual-wielded; "Cavalry" model with wooden grips |
| Randolph Scott |
Steve Farrell |
Colt Dragoon |
Anachronistic; 1st Model; dual-wielded in some scenes |
| Walter Coy |
Carl |
Remington Rolling Block |
Pistol; dual-wielded in some scenes |
| Zachary Scott |
Jason Brett |
Remington Rolling Block |
Pistol; dual-wielded in some scenes |
| Zachary Scott |
Jason Brett |
Colt Dragoon |
Anachronistic; 1st Model; dual-wielded in some scenes |
| Zachary Scott |
Jason Brett |
Springfield Model 1866 |
Model 1873 Rifle; visually modified to resemble a percussion cap musket |