6 appearances across 1 title
| Actor | Firearm | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Neal McDonough | Single Action Army | Modern replica, with iron grip frames and wooden grips |
| Neal McDonough | Remington New Army | With "long cylinder" cartridge conversion, blued finish, and wooden grips |
| Neal McDonough | Henry 1860 | Uberti replica, with brass frame |
| Neal McDonough | Sharps 1874 | Continuity error; Uberti replica |
| Neal McDonough | Winchester Model 1866 "Yellow Boy" | Anachronistic; Uberti replica, Saddle Ring Carbine; with sling attached |
| Neal McDonough | Winchester Model 1892 Saddle Ring Carbine | Anachronistic; Saddle Ring Carbine |