| Actor | Character | Firearm | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cameron Mitchell | Clint Allison | Single Action Army | "Arillery" model, "Quick-Draw" model; both with wooden grips |
| Clark Gable | Colonel Ben Allison | Single Action Army | - |
| Clark Gable | Colonel Ben Allison | Winchester Model 1873 | - |
| Jane Russell | Nella Turner | Single Action Army | - |
| Jane Russell | Nella Turner | Winchester Model 1873 | - |
| Robert Ryan | Nathan Stark | Remington Double Derringer | With blued finish and wooden grips |
| Robert Ryan | Nathan Stark | Single Action Army | "Artillery" model with wooden grips |