| Kaiwi Lyman |
John Wesley Hardin |
Colt 1851 Navy |
Nickle-plated with ivory grips, dual-wielded |
| Kris Kristofferson |
George Knox |
Remington 1858 New Army |
- |
| Luke Hemsworth |
Wild Bill Hickok |
Colt 1851 Navy |
dual-wielded, aged ivory grips |
| Trace Adkins |
Phil Poe |
Colt 1849 Pocket |
- |
| Bertrand-Xavier Corbi |
Sullivan |
Colt 1851 Navy |
Uberti replica, Richards-Mason Conversion with 5.5" barrel and ejector rod removed |
| Bertrand-Xavier Corbi |
Sullivan |
Double Barreled Percussion Shotgun |
With sawed-off barrel and full stock |
| Christopher M. Walker |
Jessie |
Colt 1851 Navy |
Uberti replica, Richards-Mason Conversion with 5.5" barrel |
| Christopher M. Walker |
Jessie |
Remington New Army |
With blued finish and wooden grips |
| Christopher Troy |
Sodbuster |
Colt 1851 Navy |
Uberti replica, Richards-Mason Conversion with 5.5" barrel |
| Greg Nasca |
Unger |
Colt 1851 Navy |
Uberti replica, Richards-Mason Conversion with 5.5" barrel and ejector rod removed |
| Manu Intiraymi |
Slade |
Colt 1851 Navy |
Uberti replica, Richards-Mason Conversion with 5.5" barrel |
| Robert Catrini |
Sheriff Akers |
Colt 1851 Navy |
Modern replica, with iron grip frames and custom ivory grips |
| Luke Hemsworth |
Wild Bill Hickok |
Remington New Army |
Dual-wielded; with blued finish and wooden grips |
| Luke Hemsworth |
Wild Bill Hickok |
Webley RIC No.1 New Model |
Anachronistic; with nickel-plated finish |
| Peter Sherayko |
Trail Boss |
Colt 1851 Navy |
Modern replica, with brass grip frames and wooden grips |
| Kris Kristofferson |
George Knox |
Remington New Army |
With blued finish and wooden grips |
| Kris Kristofferson |
George Knox |
Double Barreled Percussion Shotgun |
Seen only in film's poster; with sawed-off barrel |
| Trace Adkins |
Phil Poe |
Colt 1851 "U.S. Marshal" |
Anachronistic |
| Trace Adkins |
Phil Poe |
Webley RIC No.1 New Model |
Anachronistic; with nickel-plated finish |
| Jason Lively |
Ikey |
Colt 1851 Navy |
Modern replica, with brass grip frames and wooden grips |