| James Stewart |
Ransom "Rance" Stoddard |
Colt 1862 Navy |
Richards-Mason cartridge conversion with nickel-plated finish |
| John Wayne |
Tom Doniphon |
Single Action Army |
"Quick-Draw" model with hard rubber grips |
| John Wayne |
Tom Doniphon |
Winchester Model 1892 Saddle Ring Carbine |
Saddle Ring Carbine |
| Lee Marvin |
Liberty Valance |
Single Action Army |
- |
| Lee Van Cleef |
Reese |
Single Action Army |
"Artillery" model, "Quick-Draw" model; both with wooden grips |
| Woody Strode |
Pompey |
Winchester Model 1892 Saddle Ring Carbine |
Anachronistic; Saddle Ring Carbine |